Sunday, November 22, 2026

The Dog Stars: A Poignant Journey Through a Post-Apocalyptic World

Published:

The Dog Stars explores a myriad of themes, most of which are rather grim to ponder.

It delves into unfulfilled aspirations, centering on a middle-aged, out-of-practice poet who finds himself working in a manual labor job that he neither enjoys nor values. The narrative also reflects on the futility of ambition; the same man struggles to carve out an existence in a post-apocalyptic world, more tormented by his persistent hope for improvement than by the unsettling reality of feeding his dog jerky made from human remains.

Moreover, it tells the story of this survivor and his dog as they navigate the devastated landscape in their battered Cessna, desperately searching for remnants of beauty in a shattered world—and feeling nearly defeated when they fail. Yet, occasionally, they do stumble upon something beautiful, which, paradoxically, often causes even deeper pain.

This is essentially the premise of The Dog Stars by Peter Heller—a lyrically melancholic tale set in a post-epidemic wasteland, recounted through the perspective of Hig, a writer-turned-pilot and dog enthusiast.

However, in the film adaptation directed by Ridley Scott, the focus shifts to a cardboard cutout version of Hig, played by Jacob Elordi, who stoically seems to carry the weight of the world with a sideways grin. He embodies the last spark of humanity, juggling a hammer, wrench, or plane yoke in one hand while attempting to rescue others yet again.

WATCH | The Dog Stars Trailer:

The portrayal is of a youthful Everyman in his twenties, whose experiences we follow as he transitions from combat to sentimental monologues. It embodies a kind of after-school special hope amidst horror and includes distracting, action-packed scenes that bear little relevance to the plot but are deemed necessary by studio executives.

The film features absurdly contrived scavengers who are taken down by the protagonists like they’re mere targets—these genre-specific foes resemble either the Lost Boys from Hook or the “War Boys” from Mad Max: Fury Road.

Ultimately, the film follows the same trajectory as many other, more successful post-apocalyptic movies. Yet, it lacks the intensity or vigor that would make it genuinely gripping.

This is somewhat amusing because, when not placed alongside the widely praised and successful novel, The Dog Stars still disappoints.

Beginning with Elordi’s portrayal of Hig as a scavenger in a city reminiscent of I Am Legend, the film at least starts with the aesthetic of a survival story. Upon meeting the obstinate Bangley (played by Josh Brolin), Hig’s gruff yet irritable companion, the film hints at becoming a competent buddy movie, rooted in the chemistry between the rugged Bangley—skillfully portrayed by an actor who has long mastered this type from Deadpool to No Country For Old Men.

A man in a vest stands in a bare room.

Josh Brolin plays Bangley, Hig’s irascible soldier-of-fortune compound companion in The Dog Stars (20th Century Studios/The Associated Press)

However, this strong performance is undermined by Elordi, who, like Sydney Sweeney in The Housemaid, appears overly conscious of avoiding depth in his portrayal. His performances tend to oscillate between “smouldering” and “brooding,” seemingly overly focused on projecting a brand of cool that precludes any genuine vulnerability or human emotion. In essence, he represents the anti-Robert Pattinson.

This reluctance results in Hig often smiling awkwardly when young characters refer to him as their hero. Or coldly preparing for yet another skirmish against an adversary who is just unappealing enough to ensure the audience maintains sympathy for Hig as the clear-cut good guy amid the moral ambiguity.

Additionally, this portrayal simplifies the good-versus-evil framework, failing to challenge the audience to connect with anyone possessing realistic, relatable complexity. The film presents an overall unoffensive, oddly lighthearted take on a dystopian narrative, even going so far as to omit any reference to climate change that was woven throughout the original novel. This simplification extends to the sound design, where foley artists work overtime to sprinkle cute animal sounds throughout the audio, ensuring audiences remain sympathetic to the adorable dog at all times.

Nevertheless, the film’s shortcomings cannot be solely attributed to Elordi. Much of the blame lies with writer Mark L. Smith (The Revenant, Twisters) and the once-renowned director Scott. This creative team takes the film’s clichéd yet functional introduction and veers it into a direction that feels increasingly uneven and unengaging, straying from the book in ways that neither reinterpret nor reinforce its core themes.

The storytelling splits its focus between two characters, attempting to amplify what is essentially an introspective philosophical exploration with bombastic Michael Bay-style action. The worldbuilding starts off grounded in reality but soon devolves into absurdity, featuring tribes of survivors charging on horseback while yelling—culminating in a finale that is both ridiculous and visually unappealing, reinforcing the notion that Smith and Scott lost track of the narrative long ago.

When compared to the source material, the film feels even more disappointing. Despite reports that Heller was moved to tears after his first viewing (largely due to seeing his debut novel adapted for the screen), it’s hard to overlook how poorly this film captures the essence of what made The Dog Stars exceptional.

Part of the issue lies in the adaptation of a novel whose narrative is as much about its writing style as Cormac McCarthy’s The Road—a book to which The Dog Stars is often compared. The screenplay awkwardly shifts from a narrative told from the perspective of a poet in a world he can no longer call home to a story more focused on blending explosions with a truncated romance.

It takes poignant lines like, “I was a troll who lived at the base of a tree. Looked at the world through a scratchy scrim of needles and branches. Lived on rain, on bits of song and memory,” and transforms them into a film devoid of inner thoughts or insights into the character’s psyche. In summary, it’s a film that fails to grasp or honor the significance and strength of language.

A man crouches in a thicket while putting his arm around a dog.

The Dog Stars is set in a post-apocalyptic world, with Hig and his dog flying in their beat-up Cessna. (Fabio Lovino/20th Century Studios/The Associated Press)

Moreover, instead of reinterpreting its themes for a different format, the film simplifies and misconstrues them. It offers a shallow retelling that had Scott misinterpret the story as being about self-sufficiency, rather than the contrary.

This adaptation transforms the narrative of a man defined by his self-doubt and self-loathing into a story of a highly capable individual excelling at everything. It casts Elordi, a straightforward leading man, as the ostensibly neurotic and unraveling protagonist, while borrowing the novel’s slow-paced contemplation and mistaking it for a sense of solemn gravitas.

While the subpar direction does not solely determine the film’s fate, it certainly contributes to making The Dog Stars one of the most poorly executed post-apocalyptic adaptations since World War Z. And that is saying quite a lot.

Related articles

Recent articles